Season 5 of "24"
So far Season 5 of "24" far, far surpasses any of the previous seasons. A full review will follow when I get through all the DVD's in the next week.
reviews of a whole lot of things
So far Season 5 of "24" far, far surpasses any of the previous seasons. A full review will follow when I get through all the DVD's in the next week.
critiqued by
caddy
at
5:53 PM
0
second opinion(s)
I hate to admit it, but sometimes I’m wrong. Really, really wrong.
Based on a few short stories that I read in The New Yorker, I thought Maile Meloy was totally overrated, although her short story collection Half in Love received much critical praise. More adulation followed for her first novel, Liars and Saints, which came out in 2003. I never read either.
When I came across a copy of A Family Daughter in the library, I decided to check it out (solely based on the book jacket copy, which mentioned entanglements “with an aging French playboy, a young Eastern European prostitute, a spoiled heiress, and her aging jet-set mother”). Within minutes of opening the book, I found myself completely wrapped up in the world of the Santerre family.
A Family Daughter revolves around Abby Santerre and her complicated relationship with her family, especially her mother Clarissa and her uncle Jamie. In some ways, the novel is a coming-of-age tale, but in other ways, it is a postmodern examination of the very genre. Abby writes a novel about a fictional family similar to hers. As the publication of the book begins to change her real family’s lives, Abby feels suddenly responsible for every twist and turn in Meloy’s work.
The plot unfolds at a breezy, rapid pace. Things happen so quickly that I caught myself rereading passages to figure out what, exactly, had just happened — did Jamie really just have sex with that girl? Did that person really just die?
But this pace is part of the novel’s charm. Within the first 25 pages, Abby’s father has died. Ten pages later, she’s involved in an incestuous relationship that comes across as sweet and sexy instead of creepy, a testament to Meloy’s skill. Over the next 300 pages, relationships come and go and come back and evolve in completely unpredictable ways that are alternately hilarious and heartbreaking.
The entire novel is a reworking of Liars and Saints, which tells the story of the Santerre family from a different perspective. Since I haven’t read that novel, I can’t compare the two. All I can say is that A Family Daughter is one of the two best books I read in 2006, along with Claire Messaud’s The Emperor’s Children. Undeservedly overlooked, I hope the paperback edition of the novel in February will bring it the attention it merits.
critiqued by
caddy
at
5:51 PM
0
second opinion(s)
Rocky Who?
My punch-drunk holiday introduction to the Italian Stallion
Nothing quite says Christmas peace and joy like a boxing flick. Blood, punches, fighting and the triumph of the will — what could be more representative of the birth of baby Jesus?
The new (and ostensibly final) sequel to Sylvester Stallone’s Rocky, Rocky Balboa, opened three days before Christmas, following in the grand holiday tradition of movies like Million Dollar Baby, Raging Bull, Rocky IV, Rocky V, and, of course, Rocky, which probably started the whole thing.
Having never seen a single Rocky movie (seriously, this is how bad it was: I didn’t know “Gonna Fly Now (Theme from Rocky)” was the theme from Rocky until a few weeks ago when I saw a commercial for Rocky Balboa and finally connected the two), I decided to fill the giant gap in my cultural literacy by watching each movie in order (within the space of 48 hours) before venturing to the Bijou to check out the new one.
I now know more about boxing than I ever thought possible. I’m not a fan of the sport, preferring the violence of football to two men beating the hell out of each other. But now I know that a match without a knockout goes 15 rounds, that each round is three minutes and that one can literally “throw in the towel” to end the match.
I also now know that underneath the same plot in every movie (the scene is set, conflict arises, a match is set, the conflict hurts the training for the match, the conflict is resolved, training for match improves, the match happens, Rocky starts off losing the match, then comes back improbably and drags it out for a long time to either win or tie), the series of films reflect a society’s changing cultural anxieties about race, gender, class and aging.
The first Rocky was released in time for the holidays in 1976. Although its most recognized scene is Rocky running up the stairs in front of the Philadelphia Museum of Art (a scene referenced in every subsequent film), the movie is actually a quiet character study that went on to win three Oscars.
Rocky Balboa is a small-time hood with a heart of gold that sees the beauty in the quiet, mousy Adrian (Talia Shire). When heavyweight champion Apollo Creed (Carl Weathers) decides to fight Rocky because of his nickname, “The Italian Stallion,” Rocky is forced to prove to himself that his longtime dabbling in boxing will allow him to go the distance with the champ.
Sylvester Stallone wrote the script himself, as he did for every other Rocky movie. The film has a slow pace, and the movie ends just after the climatic fight scene, as Adrian pushes her way through the crowd to hug the semi-victorious Balboa, as the 15-round fight is a split decision going to Creed.
Rocky and Rocky II, a rematch with Creed released in the summer of 1979, clearly reflect the unease of the 1970s. Both films take place in economically depressed sections of Philadelphia — other than the museum, the streets of the town are dingy and grim.
In the original film, Creed makes it clear he wants to fight a white boxer, highlighting a cultural anxiety about the rise of black athletes. In the sequel, Rocky is forced to fight the rematch after he fails to provide for his family with commercial endorsements after the first fight, to the dismay of his wife.
“I didn’t stop you from being a woman, don’t stop me from being a man,” Rocky shouts.
Adrian almost loses her baby and falls into a coma after working too hard outside the home; when she wakes up, she is fully in support of her husband (and never works again in any of the remaining movies).
I know that Rocky’s love for Adrian is supposed to be his defining characteristic throughout the films, showing that he is a fighter with “heart,” but I never bought their relationship. Only in Rocky Balboa, in which the mourning Rocky returns to the ring to get over his grief at losing his wife (and growing old himself) does their relationship seem to have any kind of resonance.
Rocky is a great movie — beautifully filmed, carefully considered, one of the all-time classic sports movies. The newest film echoes the first one in many ways, in its pace and lack of an actual win in Rocky’s final match.
But after watching every film, I have to say that Rocky III, released in the summer of 1982, is the best one. Not only is this the film in which “Eye of the Tiger” becomes the new theme song of Rocky (although Bill Conti still scores the film), and not only does Rocky fight Hulk Hogan (once) and Mr. T (twice), but this was the only film that I actually found myself rooting for Rocky to win.
Rocky III explores the fleeting nature of fame once the underdog is the top dog. Rocky gets knocked out by Mr. T’s character, Clubber Lang, so Apollo Creed (who becomes Rocky’s trainer after his longtime trainer Mickey Goldmill (Burgess Meredith) dies) takes Rocky to the slums of L.A. to train for the rematch.
The difference between this movie and the first two is the difference between filmmaking in the 1970s and the 1980s. This is a movie focused on a plot, a soundtrack and lot of fighting. It is also a lot of fun to watch.
Rocky IV, however, is just terrible. Despite starring Dolph Lundgren as Soviet boxer Ivan Drago and Brigitte Nielsen as his wife, this 1985 movie’s only redeeming feature is the over-the-top performance of the late James Brown singing “Living in America.”
Rocky V is pretty terrible, too — the dialogue is leaden, the flashbacks are trite. But it is the only film in the series to end not with a bout in the ring but a full-out street brawl, between Rocky and his former protégé, Tommy Gunn (real-life boxer Tommy Morrison), which Rocky, of course, wins.
Rocky Balboa is, in its way, a brave film. Stallone directed the film (he also directed Rocky II, Rocky III and Rocky IV) and clearly realizes how ridiculous it is for a 60-year-old to attempt climbing back into the ring against the young heavyweight champion Mason “The Line” Dixon, played by boxer Antonio Tarver.
Balboa’s arguments about his return to boxing with the Pennsylvania Athletic Commission (to get his license) and then his son Robert (a.k.a. Rocky, Jr., played by Milo Ventimiglia of Gilmore Girls fame) sound like arguments Stallone must have had with the studio heads to get this film made.
In the final fight scene, despite his extensive training, Stallone’s flesh sags and jiggles in sharp contrast to Tarver’s smooth muscle-bound skin. It’s gross. But it is also courageous — he is willing to make a fool of himself, but, surprisingly, he doesn’t.
Rocky Balboa is an homage to all previous Rocky movies. It also returns to the series the sly humor of the first three films.
If you liked the films, if they were a part of your childhood, then you’ll enjoy the movie. If you somehow escaped watching Rocky, go rent the first one, at least, before seeing the new one.
Better yet, watch them all and be filled with your own punch-drunk love for Stallone.
critiqued by
caddy
at
5:50 PM
0
second opinion(s)
Books of the Year
1. “The Emperor’s Children” by Claire Messaud - Forget the backlash, and just go read it.
2. “Special Topics in Calamity Physics” by Marisha Pessl - Not as good as everyone said, but still highly entertaining and clever.
3. “A Family Daughter” by Maile Meloy - I have a new favorite author. This book is so awesome that I cannot believe I ever disliked her short stories in The New Yorker. It is funny, sad and sexy. Go read it now!
4. “Heat” by Bill Buford - If you like food, you will like this book.
5. The Whole World Over” by Julia Glass - This second novel by the NBA-winning Glass got little attention and kind of falls apart in the end. But the writing is beautiful, the characters are deeply felt, and I really loved it.
Books I haven’t read yet but would probably be on my list if I had not just gotten them for Christmas or had not had to return them to the library
1. “The Echo Maker” by Richard Powers - I started this, and it was recalled from the library. So far, so good ... that is to say, a lot more awesome than “Galatea 2.0,” which I enjoyed but thought was overrated. Is it worth the National Book Award? Time will tell.
2. “The Night Watch” by Sarah Waters - Wow, what a change of pace from the sublime Waters! Shortlisted for the Booker, it tells a deeply affecting story backwards. I can’t wait until I can get it again from the library so I can find out what happens.
3. “The Blind Side: Evolution of a Game” by Michael Lewis - This book was excerpted in the NYT Magazine and made me cheer and cry. I can’t wait to read the whole book.
4. “The View from Castle Rock” by Alice Munro - There’s no way this is not going to be great.
Worst book of the year, even though I haven’t read it
1. “The Lay of the Land” by Richards Ford - I HATE HATE HATE Frank Bascombe. “Independence Day” is one of the most insufferable novels I have ever had the displeasure to read. (I read it on a bet from B. that I couldn’t get through it in a week. As if!) Who cares about some middle-aged white guy having yet another stupid middle-aged crisis? Tedious, unpleasant and incredibly overrated.
Dinner of the year
1. My 29th birthday at St. John’s
2. Union Square Cafe in December
3. Chez Panisse in May
4. WD-50 last Christmas Eve just before the start of 2006
5. A few trips to 5 & 10
6. A lot more trips to St. John’s and the Meeting Place
7. Sotto Sotto (three times)
8. Kyma
9. Sally's, always the best pizza in the whole wide world
10. Pura Vida
Clothes of the year
1. BCBG bubble skirt that I have worn non-stop all month
2. My sister’s black skirt that I took over after she left for Africa
3. Strapless brown dress that I stole from my mom
4. Blue Velvet dress I got at Anthropologie for my birthday
5. Juicy trench coat
Things I finally decided to like in 2006 that I had previously rejected
1. Juicy Couture
2. The Killers
3. Death Cab for Cutie
4. “24”
5. “Veronica Mars”
Things I tried to like in 2006 but still can’t stand
1. Pickles
2. Bright Eyes
3. The Tennessee Vols (ok, I never really tried to like them, but living here, it’s hard to not get immersed in the media coverage)
Best fashion trends
1. Bubble skirts
2. Big bags
Worst fashion trends
1. Skinny jeans
2. Leggings
3. Skinny jeans tucked into boots
Best album
1. Phoenix - “It’s Never Been Like This Before” (easily my album of the year)
2. Ghostface Killah - “Fishscale”
3. Justin Timberlake - “FutureSex/LoveSounds”
Best song
1. “When You Were Young” - The Killers
2. “Crazy” - Gnarls Barkley
3. “Stuck Between Stations” - The Hold Steady (yeah, yeah, I know, but after Ben played it about 8,000 times I finally started liking this song - verdict is still out on the band)
Most disappointing album
1. Gnarls Barkley - “St. Elsewhere”
critiqued by
caddy
at
5:46 PM
2
second opinion(s)